4

After the river my opponent showed his hand. Thinking I had a worse hand, I threw my cards face down beyond the line but far away from any other cards. When the dealer was about to take them and muck them I realized I had a winning hand and tried to show my cards but the dealer said I mucked.

Was my hand still live since my cards were not mixed with any other cards and it was clear which my cards were?

  • 1
    I suggest you to change the title from "folded" to "mucked" – David Aug 23 at 10:52
4

If it's a tournament following the official TDA rules then the following applies:

14: Live Cards at Showdown

Discarding non-tabled cards face down does not automatically kill them; players may change their minds and table cards that remain 100% identifiable and retrievable. Cards are killed by the dealer when pushed into the muck or otherwise rendered irretrievable and unidentifiable.

See: TDA rules.

If it's not a tournament or the official TDA rules do not apply then individual house rules apply. Ask to see the house rules.

It's very common that a mucked hand is declared dead in those scenarios. It was the trend in the past and remains so in many house rules. I believe this got only recently changed in the TDA rules to be more recreational friendly.

  • First time I ever hear of TDA, so I guess they don't! – David Aug 23 at 7:19
  • @David TDA is extremely well established within the industry as being one of the major rule sets that is often used or a variation of it is used during major tournaments. Nice answer Jonast92, to the point and very clear. – Grinch91 Sep 4 at 19:18
  • @Grinch91 I am afraid we are in front of yet another case of Amero-centrism! – David Sep 5 at 7:13
  • Hmmm I'm not sure I follow, I'm not American, but have been a poker dealer mostly in the EU and WSOP for one year. It's pretty well established globally, AFAIK PokerStars is still running all it's events globally under TDA. – Grinch91 Sep 5 at 9:36
  • @David Most tournaments follow the TDA rules or a variation of it. Most people don't know which rules they are playing by though when they're playing. – Jonast92 Sep 5 at 10:12
0

This one comes up often. It's a slightly gray area. There are two issues:

Retrievable cards Generally, cars that are "retrievable" can be live. Despite what people say, "touching the much" literally means nothing in a casino. If you didn't say "fold" and you're still holding your cards, they are usually live.

Induced Action However! If your balk caused another player to act, you might very well have a dead hand. Many houses have a "forward action" rule. If your forward action [either putting chips forward or your cards] - in turn - caused another player to act - in turn - your forward action is binding.

So if you're facing a bet, and you push chips forward, it's either a call or a raise if someone acts behind you in turn. If, facing a bet, you push your cards forward, causing the player behind you to act, your hand is dead. In a heads up situation, your cards should be live.

HOWEVER.... This is a really tricky rule.

If this happened to me [well it HAS happened to me], here is what you do: Just squat. Refuse to give up your cards, seat, or money. Call the floor, call the shift, and finally call security. You have a solid chance of winning this argument. If it was a cash game, and they are taking the pot, I'd tell them I'm taking my live hole cards home with me.

-2

No, particular in this scenario your cards considered as mucked and cannot play even your throw them away by mistake and even if they were not mixed with other cards.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.